Proposed tribal casino sparks tensions in California
Metadata
- Proposed tribal casino sparks tensions in California
- November 26, 2024
- Article Body Text WASHINGTON — <p>The Koi Nation, a small Native American tribe with fewer than 100 members, is moving closer to building a $600 million Las Vegas-style casino resort in California’s Sonoma County, just an hour north of San Francisco.</p> <p>The Bureau of Indian Affairs has released its final environmental impact statement for the proposed Shiloh Resort and Casino, marking a key step in the tribe's application to place 27 hectares of land into federal trust.</p> <p>The <a class="wsw__a" href="https://www.shilohresortenvironmental.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Koi-Nation-Shiloh-Resort-and-Casino-FEIS_508.pdf" target="_blank">environmental report</a> analyzed the project's potential impacts on air and water quality, wildlife, traffic, and other factors. While most effects were deemed "less than significant," some were classified as "potentially significant." The public now has 30 days to review the findings and submit comments before the bureau makes a final decision.</p> <p>The Shiloh project faces stiff opposition from <a class="wsw__a" href="https://www.politico.com/f/?id=00000192-77d6-d344-adb2-fff7d0d10000" target="_blank">California lawmakers</a>, Governor Gavin Newsom, and neighboring tribes. Newsom argued in an <a class="wsw__a" href="https://tribalbusinessnews.com/images/2023/Gov_Newsom_letter_-_Shiloh_and_Scotts_Valley_projects_circ_8-16-2024.pdf" target="_blank">August letter </a>to the Department of the Interior that the land in question lies outside the Koi Nation’s historical homeland — a key requirement under federal law for gaming approval.</p> <figure><img src="https://gdb.voanews.com/fa87ac3a-2ad6-4b1f-8fa4-decae7cba094_w1600_r0_n_s.jpg" /><figcaption>California Gov. Gavin Newsom speaks at the San Diego Zoo, Aug. 8, 2024, in San Diego. Newsom opposes the Koi Nation's plans to develop a casino resort in Sonoma County. (AP Photo/Derrick Tuskan, File)</figcaption></figure> <p>Competing tribes, most notably the <a class="wsw__a" href="https://gratonrancheria.com/new-ads-urge-interior-secretary-deb-haaland-to-respect-tribal-sovereignty/" target="_blank">Federated Indians of Graton Rancheria</a>, also oppose the project. They launched a high-profile media campaign earlier this month with full-page ads in major newspapers accusing the Interior Department of undermining tribal sovereignty.</p> <p>Attorney Gabe Galanda, an enrolled member of the Round Valley Indian Tribes of California, says the proposed casino “is about tribes forsaking their teachings and falsifying history for profit. It’s a dangerous precedent for intertribal relationships.”</p> <p>At the heart of the controversy is the <a class="wsw__a" href="https://www.nigc.gov/general-counsel/indian-gaming-regulatory-act" target="_blank">Indian Gaming Regulatory Act</a> of 1988, which sets the rules for tribal gaming and includes guidelines about a tribe’s historical connection to land. The casino must be located on land the federal government holds in trust for the tribe. The act also prohibited gaming on lands acquired after October 17, 1988, unless certain conditions are met.</p> <p>One such exception applies to tribes with restored federal recognition. In December 2023, the Biden administration announced an updated final rule that made it easier for tribes to acquire land in trust. The rule now permits gaming on lands placed into trust as part of restoring territory to a landless tribe that has regained federal recognition.</p> <p>To qualify for this exception, a tribe must demonstrate both a historical and contemporary connection to the land.</p> <figure><img src="https://gdb.voanews.com/2ced65f7-f1ad-4dac-8e32-e2b1f3424231_w1600_r0_n_s.jpg" /><figcaption>"Man in Pomo dance costume," 1924 photo by Edward S. Curtis. Koi Naiton tribe members are descended from the Southeastern Pomo people living on the island village of Koi in Clear Lake, California.</figcaption></figure> <p>For the Koi Nation, the fight is deeply personal. In 1916, the federal government recognized the tribe under its former name, the Lower Lake Rancheria, and allocated 56 hectares of land in neighboring Lake County which were largely <a class="wsw__a" href="https://www.google.com/books/edition/The_Pomo_of_Lake_County/7JZFJWRrXjIC?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=Purvis+Flats+lower+lake+rancheria&pg=PA42&printsec=frontcover" target="_blank">unfarmable</a>. By 1918, most tribal members had relocated to Sonoma County.</p> <p>In 1956, the federal government sold off 40 hectares of the Lake County land and transferred the remaining 16 hectares to the sole tribal member still residing there.</p> <figure><img src="https://gdb.voanews.com/39d55371-3b47-4d86-90cb-37d573af5f8b_w1600_r1_n_s.png" /><figcaption>Detail from 1884 map of Sonoma County, California.</figcaption></figure> <p>The Interior Department did not officially terminate the tribe; through clerical errors, it simply forgot about them. Decades later, the government reaffirmed that relationship.</p> <p>“The Lower Lake Rancheria have been officially overlooked for many years by the Bureau of Indian Affairs even though their government-to-government relationship with the United States was never terminated,” then-assistant Indian affairs secretary Kevin Gover stated in his <a class="wsw__a" href="https://www.bia.gov/as-ia/opa/online-press-release/assistant-secretary-gover-reaffirms-federal-trust-relationship-king" target="_blank">December 29, 2000 finding</a>. “I am pleased to correct this egregious oversight.”</p> <p>The Koi purchased the Shiloh land for $12.3 million in 2021 and <a class="wsw__a" href="https://www.koinationsonoma.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/Koi-Nation-Request-for-Restored-Land-Opinion.pdf" target="_blank">applied</a> to the government to place the land into trust. The tribe says that trails their ancestors used in trade pass directly through the site.</p> <p>“The Koi Nation has been in this region for thousands of years and is fully within its rights to pursue this project,” said Sam Singer, a spokesperson for the tribe.</p> <p>Singer attributes much of the opposition to fear of competition. Currently, more than 60 tribes operate 66 casinos across California. The Graton Rancheria operates a resort and casino about 17 kilometers south of the Shiloh property and is currently undergoing a $1 billion expansion.</p> <p> </p>
- Content Type Text
- Language English
- NewsML Media Topics Arts, Culture, Entertainment and Media
- Subtitles / Dubbing Available No
- Network VOA
- Embargo Date November 26, 2024 15:51 EST
- Byline Cecily Hilleary
- Brand / Language Service Voice of America - English